IMG_8402.JPG

Greetings.

Welcome to the launch of The South Dakota Standard! Tom Lawrence and I will bring you thoughts and ideas concerning issues pertinent to the health and well-being of our political culture. Feel free to let us know what you are thinking.

The trouble with one-and-done financial solutions like loan consolidations

The trouble with one-and-done financial solutions like loan consolidations

Sometime the solution to a money problem seems to be a “one and done” fix. Maybe you’re having trouble paying bills and are accumulating debt. Then you receive an unexpected tax refund, get a raise, or refinance your mortgage, so everything should be better. Each of those can help, but none of them by itself changes the underlying patterns that caused the problem.

A debt consolidation loan is a clear example. It may provide lower rates and payments that offer a respite. Yet the relief may not last.  A 2023 study by TransUnion, titled “Debt Consolidation in a Rising Economy,” found that people who used a personal loan to pay off credit cards cut their card balances by 57 percent on average. For many of them, the balances were nearly back to their earlier levels 18 months later. The loan could not change the circumstances and the spending that built the debt in the first place.

In my podcast interview with Olena Keshysheva, a Certified Financial Planner in Canada who practices financial therapy, she drew a line between two forms of change that people mix up. One she calls healing, which is what happens when someone breaks an arm, comes down with an illness, or even suffers a great loss like a natural disaster or a death in the family. Whether the incident is large or small, there is something specific to recover from. The other she calls evolution, which is a gradual process that happens over a period of time.

Changing most money habits requires the second kind of recovery. A pattern that took years to build rarely changes in a single event, even one that does a great deal to solve an immediate problem. Olena says, “The transformation happens over a lifetime.”

Working with a financial therapist more commonly involves the longer process of evolution rather than healing. Several years ago I wrote about two examples. One person was able to resolve his chronic money anxiety in five financial therapy sessions. A couple had worked with a financial therapist for more than ten years and, while they had made progress, were still overspending. Unfortunately, the longer the healing takes, the deeper the financial hole can get.

One strategy that tends to work is committing to a change small enough that you can stay present while you’re making it. Many of us, when we identify a money problem and try to fix it, choose a solution that matches how bad we feel about the problem. Often, this level of solution is big enough to overwhelm us. Then the part of us that handles being overwhelmed takes over and does what it knows how to do—which is return to the old behavior.

The kind of solution we are more able to maintain is one with less emotional weight, one that fits an ordinary week. Here’s what that may mean in practice. Instead of vowing to save your entire bonus, set up an automatic transfer to move $10 or $20 a week into saving. Instead of promising to review all your financial information every month, commit to deliberately opening one statement. A smaller, slower change that you can maintain is likely to serve you better than a larger one you abandon after nine days.

At times, of course, a large change can still be the right call. A consolidation loan, a new job, or a move may be part of the solution. It’s important, however, to see such an action as not as a fix to the problem, but as the beginning of the work. It is just one step toward changing your money behavior.

Rick Kahler, CFP®, CFT™, is a pioneer in financial therapy and a 2026 inductee into the Financial Therapy Hall of Fame. He is the founder of The Financial Therapy Podcast and Kahler Financial Group, and co-author of “Coupleship Inc.” and “The Financial Wisdom of Ebenezer Scrooge.

The information provided is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice. The views expressed are subject to change based on market or economic conditions. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Any reference to potential benefits is illustrative and may not apply to your individual circumstances. You should consult with your financial adviser before making any investment decisions. KFG, LLC is an SEC-registered Investment Adviser.

Photo: public domain, wikimedia commons

The South Dakota Standard is offered freely and is supported by our readers. We have no political or commercial sponsorship. If you'd like to help us continue our mission to advance independent political and social commentary, you can do so by clicking on the "Donate" button that's on the sidebar to your right.     



Farmers look to new Congress to fix damage caused by Trump

Farmers look to new Congress to fix damage caused by Trump